4th Street East & Brazil Street Hillside Residential Projects

In August and September of 2017, the City of Sonoma Planning Commission approved separate applications for the development of three residences on three lots in northeast Sonoma (at Fourth Street East and Brazil Street) having a zoning designation of Hillside Residential. Those approvals were subsequently appealed to the City Council.

At the Special City Council Meeting on April 9, 2018, the City Council voted 3-2  to uphold the appeals and deny the approvals of the proposed hillside homes due to insufficient environmental review and noncompliance with the General Plan, Hillside Ordinance and other municipal code.

1. 149 Fourth Street East

      a. Appeal
      b. Applicant’s Response
      c. Architect Statement
      d. Plans/Elevations/Grading
      e. Presentation - 1 of 3
           Presentation - 2 of 3
           Presentation - 3 of 3

2. Lot 228

      a. Appeal
      b. Applicant’s Response
      c. Architect Statement
      d. Plans/Elevations/Grading
      e. Presentation - 1 of 3 (also addresses Lot 227)
           Presentation - 2 of 3
           Presentation - 3 of 3

3. Lot 227

      a. Appeal
      b. Applicant’s Response  
      c. Architect Statement
      d. Plans/Elevations/Grading
      e. (Refer to A.2.e)

4. Common Materials

      a. Detention Analysis 1 of 2
           Detention Analysis 2 of 2
      b. Neighborhood Drainage An

1. 149 Fourth Street East

a. Planning Commission Staff Report
b. Final Conditions of Approval
c. Project Narrative
d. Plans/Elevations/Grading/Tree Diagram page 1 of 2
Plans/Elevations/Grading/Tree Diagram page 2 of 2
e. Visual Analysis 1 of 2
Visual Analysis 2 of 2
f. Initial Study (See B.4 for attachments to the Initial Study)

2. Lot 228 (Brazil Street Lot 3)

a. Planning Commission Staff Report
b. Final Conditions of Approval
c. Project Narrative
d. Plans/Elevations/Grading/Tree Diagram
e. Visual Analysis
f. Initial Study (See B.4 for attachments to the Initial Study)

3. Lot 227 (Brazil Street Lot 4)

a. Planning Commission Staff Report
b. Final Conditions of Approval
c. Project Narrative
d. Plans/Elevations/Grading/Tree Diagram
e. Visual Analysis
f. Initial Study (See B.4 for attachments to the Initial Study)

4. Common Materials

a. Planning Commission Minutes (March 9, 2017, August 10, 2017, September 14, 2017)
b. Inman Letter
c. Biological Report
d. Cultural Resources Analysis
e. Preliminary Grading and Drainage Plan
f. Arborist Reports
g. Peer Review of Arborist Report

1. Public Correspondence - Deny Appeal
2. Public Correspondence - Support Appeal 
3. Additional Correspondence Received After the Posting of the Agenda, Part A
4. Additional Correspondence Received After the Posting of the Agenda, Part B
5. Additional Correspondence Received March 1, 2018, Part C
6. Additional Correspondence Received March 1, 2018, Part D
7. Additional Correspondence Received March 1, 2018, Part E
   
8. Additional Correspondence Received April 9, 2018